According to the book it was the Messerschmitt BF-109E which means no one technically won this round. The anwser being that "nearly 36,000" produced. The actual number is kind of hazy though do to retooling and using other parts etc.
Here is a good article that might interest you on the 109 and it includes some nice art photos of the plane.
http://www.aviation-history.com/mess...itt/bf109.html
However all that said I would have to say KG_Soldier was the winner as it looks like the IL-2 had more produced if 36,172 is correct. Great Job!
If you guys like this kind of thing I have plenty more and will post new ones periodically.